On suffering
–
W. H. Auden, in the second stanza of his “Musee des Beaux Arts,” refers to Pieter Brueghel’s painting Landscape with the Fall of Icarus to illustrate his insight into human suffering and death.
In the painting, Auden points to the farmer plowing his field and to ship (and its crew) turning away from the sight of a boy falling down from the sky and splashing into the water. For them, the sight may be quite extraordinary but not that significant to make them stop what they are doing. Even the fisherman, seen on the lower right of the painting, does not seem to be surprised by the sight. He does not even look at the boy falling into the water, and goes on with his fishing. And why would they?
Even the “sun shone / as it had to on the white legs disappearing into the green / water”; but only because it HAD TO, and not because such human drama is worth its special attention. What may have happened to the boy would be the concern really of Icarus himself or his father Daedalus (or perhaps to high school students and their teachers who study the mythic tale in class for its lesson on overreaching).
But that is the nature of misfortune, right? It is earthshaking only to the people who suffers from it. The rest of humanity it seems could not care less. Or do they?










COMMENTS